Commentary: Correct Act 46

This commentary originally appeared in The Caledonian Record. You may read it on their website here.

Click here to contact your legislator and ask them to stop the shenanigans before there is too much damage done to our schools.

Correct Act 46

To the Editors:

I am writing to appeal to Vermont’s legislators to help remedy some of the considerable damage that the uncertainty surrounding Act 46 has done to Vermont’s small towns -such as my home town of Cabot- when they convene in January. Remedies might include maintaining small school grants, reforming special education funding and administration, reforming school funding, and promoting initiatives to support the economic health and vitality of rural communities; such as an expansion of broadband access, funding for community economic vitalization, and education and training relevant for rural Vermont.


The criteria defined in Act 46 for the Agency of Education and the State Board of Education to decide the fate of schools did not consider the economic consequences of school closures on community vitality and cohesion or the economic wellbeing of rural Vermont. When schools close, fewer young families choosing a place to raise a family will locate there. That adversely affects life in small towns because young families bring new ideas, entrepreneurship, community spirit, and volunteer service. Also, when high schools close, real estate values gradually decline, further stressing school funding, funding for maintenance of town roads, fire and emergency protection, water and wastewater treatment and other vital services.

Families with high school age children observing the Act 46 process and the possibility of their high school closing must decide whether to face long bus rides and reduced access to school sports, relocate or to rush to apply for a school choice lottery. Thus, it should be expected that rural enrollment drops for reasons that may have nothing to do with the quality of the education offered. Now that the damage has been done, the legislature can and must redress some of these adverse consequences and improve conditions for a sustainable future of the affected towns.

A good place to start would be to help schools recover from the possibly temporary decline in student population caused by Act 46. It is critical to retain small school grants. Reform of special education and a shift of more of the tax burden from a real estate to income would also help to sustain taxpayer support for schools and other town services. Beyond steps that directly support schools, the legislature could help small towns by renewed efforts to expand broadband internet access, support for entrepreneurship and other economic vitalization initiatives and education and training with specific relevance for rural Vermont.

If others share these above concerns, please let your legislators know.


Niels Larsen

Cabot, Vermont




Here are three easy ways you can help Campaign for Vermont in our fight for a more prosperous and economically secure Vermont.

  1. Make a financial contribution. Your support will go directly toward engaging an educated public in issues of vital importance and putting people in the statehouse to fight for you.
  2. Contact your legislator and ask them what they are doing for you. Politicians work for us. In the words of Dwight D. Eisenhauer, “we the people elect leaders not to rule, but to serve.”
  3. Follow us on social media. Keep up with the latest updates and opportunities for action.

Showing 1 reaction

Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.
  • Sukie N. Knight
    commented 2019-02-06 23:00:55 -0500
    Vermonters are well capable of building, supporting and overseeing all aspects of our local schools. This is called LOCAL CONTROL. The legialators did lousy if any research prior to passing this anomaly called Act 46. Rescind this act of foolishness now. Find some worthy laws to pass. Stop shaking our foundations. We live in a country and state established as a GOVERNMENT OF BY AND FOR THE PEOPLE. ALL THE PEOPLE. A few legislators are not all the people. Our power is being usurped from us by this awful law.

Donate Volunteer Reduce Property Tax Burden


get updates