Deep Fakes in Elections (S.23) - Overview & Analysis

The bill aims to regulate the use of synthetic media (specifically deepfakes) in elections by requiring the disclosure of deceptive and fraudulent synthetic media within 90 days of an election.

The Details:

  • The bill defines "deceptive and fraudulent synthetic media" as any synthetic representation of an individual intended to mislead voters, harm a candidate's reputation, or unduly influence the outcome of an election.

  • The definition includes images, audio, or video of a candidate’s appearance, speech, or conduct created or manipulated using digital technology or AI without the candidate’s consent.
  • The bill mandates that any synthetic media that meets this definition must include a clear disclosure stating "This media has been created or intentionally manipulated by digital technology or artificial intelligence." Specific guidelines for the visibility and audibility of these disclosures are also outlined, depending on whether the media is visual or audio.

  • A "reasonable person" standard of evidence is outlined in the bill. Meaning that the content would deceive a reasonable person. This is intended to filter out any content that is obviously fake.

  • Synthetic media, as outlined above, is only restricted within 90 days of an election.
  • An enforcement mechanism is provided by allowing the State's Attorney or Attorney General to take action against violations.

  • Radio, television, and streaming newscasts that regularly published general interest news content are largely exempted from this bill.

  • The bill establishes penalties for violations, with fines ranging from $1k to $15k based on the intent and prior offenses of the violator. An additional fine of $5k can be levied for obstructing investigations (e.g., destroying evidence).

  • Candidates whose representations are misrepresented through deceptive synthetic media, or the Attorney General, can seek injunctive relief under this legislation.
  • The bill would take effect upon passage.

The Good:

  • Puts protections in place to prevent deepfakes from deceiving voters leading up to an election.
  • Provides clear disclosures on AI-generated content.

The Bad:

  • Free speech concerns.
  • Potential for people sharing content on social media to inadvertently violate this law.

Analysis:

Twenty-one states have passed similar legislation and there is a growing recognition of the need to address the risks posed by deep fakes in elections. Protecting the integrity of elections and the democratic process is critical to maintaining our democracy and new AI-powered tools are making it difficult to determine what is real and what is fake.

One notable incident in Slovakia occurred where an audio deep fake circulated just before an election, suggesting a candidate wanted to rig the vote. The use of deep fakes in campaigns is concerning and almost certainly poses a risk to free and fair elections.

Other states have faced free speech challenges over similar pieces of legislation. Lawmakers will need to be careful when crafting the language to not violate free speech rights. This is one of the reasons why the bill only requires the labeling of deep fakes instead of outright banning the practice in elections.

Additionally, there is a risk that citizens or campaigns may inadvertently violate this law by sharing content on social media that they didn't realize was AI-generated. Revisions to the bill do offer some protections for persons who share content they didn't know was AI generated, but it is a "reasonable person" standard that may not be fully inclusive.

However, these are all navigable problems and some protection for campaigns against deep fake attacks would be welcome.

 

Current Status:

The Senate passed the bill via voice vote on March 20, 2025. The bill was amended by the House on June 16, 2025 and may be taken back up for consideration by the Senate when they return in January.

 

News coverage on S.23

Read the Bill

More bill summaries

Last updated: 6/18/2025

DISCLAIMER: Generative AI used to assist in the production of this report.

Showing 1 reaction

Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.

Get Newsletter Our Priorities Donate

connect

get updates